FtEC

FtEC proposal

FtEC is a group of students who want to see major positive change to, in our opinion, one of the most impactful parts of life: Education. This document lays out in an itemised list the problems we have with the current public education system and what we suggest can be changed to make it create better, more independent and more intelligent citizens of this great nation.

We would like to say, we are no experts at this, we just have lived experiences that make us want to change the system. If you disagree or can think of improvements to our proposal, please, don't hesitate to send us an email or DM. We try to reply to the more serious ones with either why we did not implement your idea, or why your idea works and how/where we are going to add it.

The main issue.

The main problem we have with the current state education system is its overwhelming focus on memorisation. We think knowledge is an important factor in a successful student but not the entire goal of school. As students ourselves we have discussed with teachers, parents and employers to come up with the skills we think students should leave school confident in. Knowledge is still a big part of that, however with the emergence of new technologies we think the education system should focus on skills for the future, not the past.

The current system is like this we think, mostly, due to the time-period in which it was designed. Post industrial revolution Britain was moving in the direction of a more equal and civilised society by today's standards. The first step of which was providing every student with the skills needed for employment at the time. So the subjects of English and Maths were held in such high regard, if you could read, write and count you would have gotten a better paid job. This focus has carried on till today, when still the necessity to read is important, but it doesn't exactly set someone apart. We believe that because the goalposts of employment have shifted so far from when the system was designed, it needs to be redesigned from the ground up to accommodate for living a successful life in today’s world.

Don’t just take our word for it, the Office of National Statistics, along with many other official bodies say: just under 1 million young people are without employment, training or education. Over 1 in 6 pupils are absent from school which is almost double what it was before Covid. The disadvantage gap is huge and GCSE results have plateaued since 2023 despite the educational changes and studies. The following is our, admittedly radical, solution:

What to do about it, Andy.

Our thinking towards our system is: The bread and butter of any system is incentives. In capitalism the incentive to contribute is money. In school, the incentive to work is grades. While we would love to stop representing a human person with ten numbers, we concede that grades are still needed if our proposals are to be taken seriously enough to happen. They remain an easy way to compare students and schools, regrettably. With this incentive we need a way to fairly establish grades for each student. In order to do this we need to decide something, what should grades reflect?

We think instead of memorization as the entire goal, we should reward many skills, such as knowledge, understanding, critical thinking, communication, creativity, collaboration, practical application, independence and work ethic/persistence. At the end of exam season a student achieves grades in each of the listed categories for each subject.

As you may have seen, we are not the only people to have this opinion. The Guardian published an article demonstrating how 74% of the over 1000 teachers interviewed thought there was too much emphasis on passing exams, and 73% said there wasn’t enough focus on preparing students for employment or teaching “soft skills” like the ones above. We think this shows that even a survey of over 1,000 teachers comes to a similar conclusion: schools need to develop skills in collaboration, communication and creativity alongside formal qualifications. We strongly recommend giving it a read.

Now we are faced with the biggest problem so far, how do we assess these inherently subjective skills in a fair and consistent way? Let’s look at the current system for inspiration. At the moment the education system assesses students’ capacity of memorisation and some critical thinking. We are writing this during an English lesson so we shall take English as an example. In the nationwide compulsory English language exam, the exams ask students to read extracts from existing literature to answer questions about them, these range from objective questions like how is X character feeling in this line, where they must simply read a quote, to essay questions. As you may be able to guess, the established system also marks subjective material objectively. Their criteria seem to focus on students’ ability to closely analyse a piece of text, identify literary devices and recognise different categories of words etc. As a result of this being rewarded, schools teach students explicitly how to know and recognise the literary devices used and categories of words, which we think is a pretty useless skill.

What we've learned is that we can make fair and unbiased guidelines for subjective skills which schools will optimise for.

We think our assessment approach is now clear: we need to assess something that is healthy for schools to optimise for. Which is why we always come back to the categories on a by-subject basis. The examinations are the most difficult part. We think, to minimise inconsistency and make the assessments as fair as possible, we should adopt a three-fold system of assessment. That being a combination of end of year exams, similar to the existing ones, possible continuous assessments where the teacher uses evidence based methods to evaluate categories like work ethic, independence and collaboration. And finally active continuous assessment, like project and presentation work to evaluate student’s skill in creativity, communication and understanding. But crucially, while each of these assessment methods should have categories they focus on, each one assesses all categories to make the most fair system possible.

“But how can you assess 9 skill categories per subject effectively without having 90 assessments” said the people who work in education in the room. Well, just as the current exams test knowledge with very minor understanding, one assessment can measure multiple skills. Especially Non-Examined assessments (NEAs) which start off by giving good insights into a students’ creativity, and work ethic, continue to see how well they think critically, collaborate and understand other’s ideas. Moving into the final part of an NEA a students’ practical application, newfound knowledge and communication. There you have one assessment that gives an insight into each of our 9 skills.

We want to explicitly bring your attention to another great benefit of having a student profile with fair scores in different skills for universities and employers. It allows different organisations to decide which skills they are looking for and prioritising, giving students a clear reward and goal for developing different skills, and organisations an easy method of comparison.

Teaching methods

We will be taking heavy inspiration from the work of Waldorf Steiner for this section. These are great ideas, please look them up.

We think above all the biggest mishap with state schools at the moment is the way they teach. It is heavily dependent on the teacher and their skill set, meaning that which teacher a student is assigned can have a significant effect on their academic achievement. We want to change that, which would both make assessments more fair and reduce the disadvantage gap. The way we can accomplish making grades less dependent on teachers is by moving from a knowledge based teaching ideology to an understanding based one. Currently not all but many teachers attempt to imbue their students with knowledge before understanding. Which takes both teacher and student a lot more time and effort than building understanding of knowledge. This is very wordy so I’ll give an example.

Currently in the English literature GCSE the students must learn quotes, understand the plot and write about a Shakespeare play. The way this is taught is largely something like: Read the play. Discuss the play. Memorise the teachers’ analysis of the play. Write the teacher's analysis about the play. In our experience, we think the best way is to allow each student to deeply understand the play, and one of the best ways to understand something is to teach it. In this context teaching it would mean doing it, and doing it means putting on a production of that play. So instead of revising and writing. The students read, practice, learn lines, and perform. I am one of a lucky few who has had the experience of both performing a Shakespeare play, and learning a Shakespeare play by the Edexcel exam board’s standard. And I can recite many lines, explain the whole plot and most importantly understand what the complex Shakespearean language is trying to convey in Twelfth Night. And I can remember the names of the main characters and some scenes from Romeo and Juliet. Now let’s play a guessing game. Which one did I perform? It was Twelfth Night. And which one did I ‘learn about’ by Edexcel’s standards? It was Romeo and Juliet. But here’s the real kicker. As a group we spent less time performing Twelfth Night than was spent on Romeo and Juliet.

To summarise: with the same class size, we spent less time, less school resources and had much more enjoyment by performing a play, instead of reading it. This is the better way of teaching. Why aren’t we using it?

AI

It’s time to talk about the big, water devouring, planet killing, potentially civilisation ending elephant in the room. AI. It’s bigger, it's better and it’s more intelligent every passing day. And everyone is using it, from my nan to my classmates to my teachers. So how does it impact our assessments?

We think the AI revolution supports our proposal hugely, as while the current system keeps rewarding written work the student isn't even gaining many skills from which employers can use at to produce better and faster. We need to change the target. Assessing skills like critical thinking, communication and knowledge along with all 9 in our list help a student in an AI future rather than hindering them with inapplicable exam technique and pure information. Assessments based on activities that AI can't do for you like communication and presentations/public speaking will become more and more relevant. In this country we have a unique opportunity to be ahead of the curve of AI in learning as this technology, whether we like it or not, is here to stay, like the computer and printing press before it. AI will impact every element of our lives, so would you rather be catching up, or pushing ahead?

IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: We think AI’s implications on humanity’s survival are significantly more important to get right than this proposal. If you like our survival too, advocate for AI safety. Support Control AI.

Fairness How fair an education system is, should be of major concern. We have been thinking about it a lot; here are our main critiques of the current system and strategies to make FtEC fair.

The current GCSE/A-level system is in no way free for unfairness, condensing an entire human into 9 numbers assessed over 6 weeks seems insane to us. Illness, domestic issues, poor mental health or financial issues that at any other time would not have a meaningful effect on your education could utterly change the trajectory of your life if they happen to affect you in the summer term of year 11/13. Put simply, this is bad. And this doesn’t even take into consideration how the way exams are structured favor certain types of thinking above others, hurting people with learning differences unfairly.

When you read this proposal we really don’t want you to think something like “oh these guys want to bring back coursework.” No. Well mostly no, we want to take what coursework could have been and make that happen. Here’s how:

The first method of assessment is student led project work. What this means practically is like coursework: a student writes, makes, performs or does in any medium some work. But unlike coursework this is 100% externally examined, without needing extra budget. The way we accomplish this is effectively if a teacher has a class of 20 who all made a piece of work, that teacher would mark 20 pieces of as similar work as possible. But those 20 pieces would be from other schools with as much info anonymised as possible. Which eliminates the bias problems of the old coursework.

Our second method of assessment is teacher observation; this is by far our weakest and most bias prone method. Which is why we intend to make it give the smallest difference to a grade possible. The reason we would like to keep it is that if a teacher really feels a student has not been accurately represented by our system they can make an appeal to judges to justify what changes they would make to the students grades with evidence. More of a fallback lest the system be inaccurate; we would also encourage students and their families to submit a similar appeal or ask a teacher to if need be. These judges we speak of would be other teachers, many of them who are not allowed to communicate and don’t know who else is working on their specific appeal. If they all judge within a margin of error whether to change or keep the grade then it changes, if they disagree it gets escalated to more teachers then a centralised body in the department for education.

Our final assessment method is ol’ reliable end of year exams. We absolutely respect that these offer a good representation of a students ability with no external help. We do not agree with the exact way GCSEs do end of year exams though. We would be very open to the use of open book assessments as they are much more realistic (in the real world you can look stuff up too) but with some rules. Firstly notes taken into the exam must be handwritten (or in the event of keyboard assess be confirmed to be typed) or sheets taken from a lesson, this prevents low effort super condensed ai notes printed just before the exam and rewards student preparation before the exam. Secondly the material in an exam must not be reproduced in the answer, this needs little explanation, it prevents a student from simply copying a model answer. Our second measure to improve end of year exams is time, it is the main limiting factor at the moment, we don’t like this as it rewards students for working quickly to a fair standard rather than working to a high standard if they are not limited. The method taken by the NZCSE is great here, they approach timed exams as something in between cutting a student off mid sentence in a strict gcse-like exam and allowing the student to take the paper away over the weekend. So we will never cut off a student during their paper but they must also not take the paper out of the exam hall and eat. This allows them to be confident they have produced their best work without being able to cheat.

Exam boards I hate exam boards, they are actively motivated not to provide the best possible education and to make the cheapest solutions to hugely impactful problems. Before Covid they used a huge amount of coursework not because it was beneficial to students or more fair but because it meant they didn’t need to bother hiring marking staff as the teachers did it for them. Then covid rolled around and A*s were being handed out more readily than branded pens on careers day which ofcourse needed reform to the systems resulting in a grade from Covid being almost incomparable to one from today. Grades being comparable is the whole goal of the current system and they reason it sacrifices so much student self development and decided it wasn’t worth teaching the nation to think, and they even failed at that. They need to go.

Ofqual is currently in charge of regulating these companies to make sure the qualifications and grades they hand out are fair and valid. The department for education sets what should be taught at school for the exam boards to base their curriculum off. Why not cut the middle man? We think if we eliminate exam boards it would firstly eliminate a large body with a lot of power over our education system who are actively incentivised not to make it its best. And secondly we can give teachers a lot more freedom to teach in the way they and their class find most effective at getting the best grades. Getting the best grades by our new assessment system regulated by other schools and based on transparency and anonymity.

Let’s do some back of the napkin calculations to guesstimate if this is doable. In 2026 ofqual priced each GCSE qualification at costing £55.80, multiply that by an average of 8 GCSEs per student and you get about £446 in qualification fees. Taking the average classroom teacher’s salary and average working hours annually and we equate 17.1 hours in additional teacher time per student before employer costs and the maintenance of the system. Therefore with our decentralised awarding system we have 17 hours of assessment time on top of existing teaching time to work with per student. Assuming they take 8 subjects that’s about 2.15 hours of dedicated marking time per student. Assuming an end of year exam takes about 30 mins to mark and a coursework takes under an hour that allows us to easily fund two end of year exams per student and a significant coursework project with time remaining for training. In short, our system is financially viable just of the savings from eliminating exam boards.

Why not?

Good question.

We think it should happen.

Do you?

We think the best way forward is to gather support. If you would like to join FtEC as a supporter or member, or discuss this proposal with us, we would love to have you! Please email hello@ftec.org.uk or see our website at ftec.org.uk. If you don’t quite have that much time or motivation on your hands, that’s fine. We would still really appreciate 5 minutes of your time to say literally anything. If you're a student, teacher, human person or AI, please just say anything! Good things, bad things, silly things. Just things. Email above.

Sources